Showing posts with label McCoy Themed Book. Show all posts
Showing posts with label McCoy Themed Book. Show all posts

Monday, June 29, 2026

MURDER WHERE THERE SHOULD BE NONE II: THIS TIME THERE IS A LOT MORE KILLING

 


Name: Demons

Author: JM Dillard

Publication Date: 7/1986

Publisher: Pocket Books (Star Trek #30)

Page Number: 251

Historian’s Note: Some time after the events of the book Mindshadow

Cast of Characters:  Captain James T. Kirk       Commander Spock              Dr. Leonard H. McCoy AKA “Bones”              Lieutenant Commander Montgomery Scott AKA “Scotty”       Lieutenant Hikaru Sulu              Lieutenant Nyota Uhura            Dr. Joseph M'Benga             Lieutenant Ingrit Tomson                   Lieutenant Stryker             Lieutenant (junior grade) Mohamed al-Baslama                Nurse Christine Chapel          Ensign Pavel Chekov              Ensign Anitra Lanter             Ensign Lisa Nguyen   Ensign Sanghoon Cho       Ambassador Sarek             Amanda Grayson              T'Ylle            T'Sai        Silek             Soltar        Starnn       

Starships and/or Starbases: USS Enterprise NCC-1701, USS Surak (Registration unknown)

Planets: Vulcan and Beekman's Planet

My Spoiler filled summary and review: The story begins with a murder.  A Vulcan scientist, named T’Ylle, is on an assignment to Beekman’s Planet researching the end of an ancient civilization that appears to have torn itself apart in madness.  The madness isn’t in the past however as her own research team comes down with it resulting in them murdering each other including her.

Sarek has a reunion with his brother, a researcher named Silek.  They haven’t seen each other in decades as Silek has been on an archaeological mission that has taken him away from Vulcan.  They have returned and Sarek is sorry to learn that his brother has recently been made a widower.  Silek reports that his father-in-law and mentor has been acting strangely even beyond the actions of a grieving father.  Sarek gets to meet this Vulcan named Starnn.  Upon meeting Sarek, Starnn gives him a gift one of the relics taken from the expedition.  Sarek refuses as it should be in a museum, but the two other Vulcans insist that he take it as they have so many of them.  It is reasoned that as an ambassador, Sarek can show the object to foreign dignitaries.  With that Sarek accepts the gift.

Sarek and Amanda

Sarek brings his brother home for a reunion with Amanda.  Silek has never met Spock but is amazed to learn that he is in Starfleet.  Amanda and Silek get caught up with information about each other’s family.  

On the Enterprise Lt. Tomson informs her second-in-command of his promotion, while a new young ensign in the Science department, who already has her PhD, defeats Mr. Spock in a chess match.  McCoy is quite taken with the beautiful young woman.  Her name is Anitra Lanter, and she can be a bit of a troublemaker.  As Captain Kirk finds out when she places a microphone in his shower and broadcasts his shower singing across the whole ship.

After being embarrassed in the shower

While this comic relief is going on the story also takes a serious turn as the officer who was happy to receive his promotion is found to have been murdered and not just killed but tortured to death.  As the crew of the Enterprise is dealing with this, on Vulcan Silek is concerned about his brother.  Sarek’s behavior is changing and the younger Vulcan feels that what happened with his expedition is happening here.

Mr. Spock discovers that it was Ensign Lanter’s responsibility for the prank played on Kirk and forces her to confess.  Kirk gives her a non-judicial punishment where she must tune up the ship’s engines. This is a task that to the unexperienced would take a number of days and she had to do it on her own time.  The Captain is somewhat amused when she inquiries about going on shore leave after she is done.  The Ensign, however, is really good at tuning up the engines and even Scotty is impressed with the results and hopes to have help out again someday.  As a result, she manages not to miss a bit of shore leave, to Kirk’s annoyance. 

Lanter being a pain in Kirk's side

  Kirk was sensitive at first to the idea of shore leave on Vulcan but so far everything seems okay.  Both Spock and McCoy seem to spend a lot of time with Ensign Lanter.  Later, Spock decides to check in on his parents.  At his childhood home Spock finds his uncle’s dead body, and he has been brutally murdered.  He locates his mother only to discover she is in a state hysteria. she tells Spock that something has taken control of his father and that before he died Silek wrote a letter to warn her.  

Spock mother is taking back to the ship.  It turns out their enemy is the closest thing to a demon in real life—hence the title of the book.  They are energy creatures that exit their containment boxes—the artifacts—by physical contact with a host.  Once they enter the body, they take control of the person’s mind and have access to all their memories and knowledge.  On top of that these aliens augment their host bodies strength and can make the body bend and twist in unnatural ways adding to the visual horror.  These aliens also are extreme sadists who enjoy torturing their victims to death. This is the reason for the murders. 

To make matters worse there is not one alien intelligence controlling their hosts but multiple, and this allows them to spread from host to host like a virus.  The only thing an infected individual needs to do to spread these tiny entities is make eye contact with an unaffected person.  In time this becomes widespread on Vulcan leading to multiple murders in places unaccustomed to any.  An officer on the Enterprise named Striker infects many crew members including Scotty who go on to infect many more. 

Crew falling under mind control

It is at this point we learn the truth about our new Ensign.  Lanter is a human being with a mutation that gives her telepathic powers.  In other words, she has the power to read minds sometimes even if she doesn’t want to.  She had been assigned to the Enterprise by Starfleet Command so Mr. Spock could help her control her powers.  This is why Spock has been spending so much time with her also intelligence became aware of possibility of the alien threat and realized her abilities would be an asset to fighting this threat.

With most of the ship under control of these demon aliens, Kirk, Spock, McCoy and Lanter lock themselves in auxiliary control.  They realize they must stop the Enterprise from traveling and infecting more planets and starships.  They plan to inflict some crippling damage to the ship that will take even the infected Scotty sometime to repair. Then they will escape by shuttle to head to Vulcan and use the research labs at the Science Academy to help find a way to destroy the “demons’ hold” on much of the population.  The whole plan starts to sour as Kirk is infected and appears to destroy the shuttle with the young Ensign on it to the horror of Dr. McCoy.  Infected Kirk gloats about the tortures he plans to put McCoy through.  It appears that Spock and McCoy are doomed but Lanter, who faked her death, gets them out of there.  All three escaped to Vulcan even though Spock really didn’t want to bring McCoy along.

Locked in Auxiliary Control

They land on Vulcan but not wanting to encounter anyone they decide to land in the desert and get head to the city on foot.  McCoy is injured and they stop at a Vulcan settlement run by Vulcans undergoing the practice of Kolinahr.  As a monastery they do not get many visitors, so they have been immune to the problem on most of Vulcan.  Spock alerts them to what is going on and asks them to take on no new students.  Spock and Lanter head out to try to solve the problem, and Spock orders McCoy to stay behind.  McCoy ignores the order and leaves and nearly gets killed again. 

Kolinahr Monastery
  

Back on the Enterprise, infected Kirk has been captured by Uhura and is then locked up alone.  This isolation cures Kirk of his infection.  Unfortunately, he soon loses Uhura to infected Sulu.  Kirk is able to lock up Tomson, and she gets better and the two of them capture the infected Sulu and Uhura.

On Vulcan, McCoy thinks he may have come up with a treatment that they could use on the infected.  Spock thinks his father would be a good guinea pig.  He goes to capture him but is severally injured in a battle with his infected father.  Lanter goes after Spock, but she gets infected as well.  The infected Sarek and Lanter capture McCoy, and they have him treat Spock’s injuries, all the while telling him of the tortures that they are going to put him and Spock though.  However, McCoy gets the jump on them when he knocks them both out with a phaser. 

It turns out the creatures thrive on spreading and feeding on the suffering of others, if an infected person is insolation for too long the entities will die.  The only exception to this is when they are in a type of suspended animation in their designer containers that we saw in the beginning of the story. McCoy mixes an anaesthetizing gas that will keep people out long enough for the evil creatures in them to die.  This works for both Sarek and Lanter.

The Enterprise enters orbit.  Kirk and some recovered crew members have gained control of the ship just as its engines were restored.  They take some fire from the Surak but manage to evade them.  Kirk gets in contact with Spock and McCoy and some explanations are given both ways.  Kirk volunteers the Enterprise to test McCoy’s gas, they transport containers of it up and put it to work. The Enterprise is normal in a few days. They then place it in the Vulcan atmosphere and peace is restored.  The remaining relicts that were untouched are placed under heavy guard.  

As the crew of the Enterprise and the population of Vulcan are recovering from what has happened, young Ensign Lanter decides Starfleet is not for her.  She has gotten what she needs to control her abilities from Mr. Spock and she feels that she is too much of a free spirit to stay in the rigid Starfleet hierarchy.  Lanter says her good-byes to Dr. McCoy and plants one more microphone in Kirk’s shower on the way out.  

Additional thoughts: This was a great Star Trek adventure. Star Trek doesn’t often do horror well just look at “Catspaw” and “Wolf in the Fold.”  This story is extremely exciting you don’t know what is going to happen next.  At any point any character can become infected, and you see no way out for the heroes.  I will add that the resolution of the story seemed to come easy.  That I think was necessary in terms of the story’s structure.  The demonic entities moved so fast that they would have overtaken the entire side of the galaxy in short time, therefore the resolution also must be able to move with great speed.   

I really enjoyed meeting Spock’s uncle Silek.  I was sad to see him die and I wish we could have seen more of him.  It was interesting in the beginning to see Sarek interacting with his brother as a peer as opposed to most of the time, he is presented as a sage giving advice.  In the book Silek is said to have a strong resemblance to Spock.  I can relate to that as I look more like my father’s youngest brother than I do him.  My favorite part is when we learn that Silek in choosing not to go into the family business of the diplomatic corps, his father stopped speaking with him and Sarek had to defy his father in order to maintain a relationship with his brother.  Since he has been on his science mission for over thirty years, he missed Spock’s birth and upbringing.  When he hears that Spock is a Starfleet officer, he lets Amanda know how impressed he is that his brother didn’t follow their father’s example and shun him.  Amanda doesn’t have the heart to tell him that he did.  Maybe Silek would still be impressed that Sarek at least got over it and returned normal relations.  We will never know.

In the book, “The Vulcan Academy Murders,” it mentioned that murder was unheard of in a thousand years on Vulcan. I titled that review “Murder Where There Should Be None.” This story puts that earlier one to shame for there wasn’t just a plan few murders but wholesale slaughter of thousands. Enough to try even cold Vulcan logic. 

I really didn’t like Lt. Tomson confrontation with Lt. Stryker.  Where she tells him that he killed her would-be-boyfriend Lt. Mohamed al-Baslama.  I really prefer Spock’s attitude when someone pointed out that his father killed his uncle he strongly responded with “My father has killed no one.” No one can be blamed for what these things did, and Tomson should be ashamed of herself. 

Ensign Lanter has been referenced by others as being a clear example of a “Mary Sue.” I disagree with that. While she certainly starts out that way I think it’s an intentional red herring.  Sues usually have a couple of traits that she is missing.  For one, Sues’ abilities are typically unexplained, however we do get an explanation: her telepathic powers.  It’s easy to repair engines when you can pull the information straight out of Scotty’s brain.  Also, she doesn’t die.  That is something that a Mary Sue is bound to do.    

When Spock and his company find themselves with the practitioners of Kloniare it makes me wonder if this is where Spock gets the idea to attempt it himself in “The Motion Picture.”  When McCoy is attacked by the le-matya, Spock makes reference to the loss of I-Chaya in the episode “Yesteryear.”

tragic encounter for young Spock

Lastly, why can’t the young Ensign Lanter leave poor Captain Kirk alone.  Do we really want to hear his shower singing all over the ship.  Does she really like Rocketman that much?

Should it be canon: I have no problem with this story being part of the official Star Trek canon as it does not conflict with anything and it’s a great story

Cover Art: The cover has Ensign Latner in civilian dress holding one of the containers that held these Demon entities. One her right is Dr. McCoy and on her left if Mr. Spock.  The cover is a lie, however, as both Spock and McCoy are dressed in their Starfleet monster maroon movie uniforms.  The story actually takes place in the last year of the five-year mission. 

Final Grade: Final Grade 5 of 5

Tuesday, February 20, 2024

THREE MEN AND A PRINCESS

 


Name: The Covenant of the Crown

Author: Howard Weinstein

Publication Date: 12/1981

Publisher: Pocket Books (Star Trek #4)

Page Number:191

Historian’s Note:  The events take place after Star Trek: The Motion Picture and before Star Trek II: The Wrath of Khan

Cast of Characters:  Rear Admiral/ Acting Captain James T. Kirk       Commander Spock              Dr. Leonard H. McCoy AKA “Bones”              Commander Montgomery Scott AKA “Scotty”       Lieutenant  Commander Hikaru Sulu              Lieutenant Commander Nyota Uhura             Lieutenant Pavel Chekov       Lieutenant Jaye Byrnes                Lieutenant Michael Howard           Lieutenant Shirn O'tay                    Lieutenant Maria Spyros            Dr. Christine Chapel          Admiral Paul Harrington          King Stevvin                Queen Meya                    Crown Princess Kailyn         First General Haim               Nars           Poder          Tolah                     Captain Kaidin                 Commander Kon         Keast          Kera

Starships and/or Starbases: USS Enterprise NCC-1701, Galileo III NCC-1701⁄7, USS Normandy NCC-4309, Starbase 22, unnamed Klingon spy ship, and IKS Nightwing

Planets: Shad, Zenna Four, Sigma 1212

My Spoiler filled summary and review: The story begins with Dr. McCoy complaining about getting old on his birthday.  To McCoy’s annoyance Kirk had thrown him a surprise birthday party.  We aren’t told how old McCoy is, but it’s old enough for McCoy to claim that he is going to get back at Kirk one day. The party is interrupted by an emergency call from Starbase 22.  When they get there, Admiral Harrington lays out the stakes.  A sector of disputed territory is in danger of falling to the Klingons. The most prosperous planet of the J sector, Shad, is in the middle of a civil war.  

The Klingons caused this civil war by arming a dissident group, the Mohd Alliance, against the central government.  The Federation backed Loyalist Coalition had been on losing end of this conflict but have now turned the tide.  The Loyalists would like the return of their monarch who had been forced into exile eighteen years ago.  Kirk has a personal connection to this war.  As a lieutenant commander, he served as an officer on USS Normandy when it visited Shad.  In his diplomatic role, he befriended the royal family and earned the respect of the King.  It was Kirk who convinced the King to go into exile with his family rather than have them all be dead martyrs.

Kirk needs to let them know its time to go!

The Enterprise is sent to Zenna Four, where the King and the rest of the royal family have spent the last eighteen years.  When they get there, however, they run into some disappointing news. First the Queen has been dead a few years, the King is dying, and the Princess does not yet seem able to take the throne.  With the King clearly in his final hours he told Kirk he never blamed him for his exile but wanted him to help his daughter continue his dynasty and restore peace to the planet. Two issues arise.  The first is the Princess Kailyn is sick.  She has choriocytosis the same condition that nearly killed Spock a number of years ago.  The disease affects each species differently, humans are immune, Vulcans start to die, but Kailyn becomes something like a diabetic, she needs daily shots to function and survive. The other issue is the sacred crown of Shad, which has been handed down since its first King, Keulane, received it from the gods and went on to unify the planet. If the Princess wants to rule, she will need the crown. When they went into exile King Stevvin hid the crown on the planet Sigma 1212. 

Looking for the missing crown

Kailyn is taking a very strong liking to Dr. McCoy; McCoy does his best to remain professional but it her crush is as plain as day.  Kirk realizes the Klingons will try to kill the royals and also, if necessary, find and destroy the sacred crown.  Kirk decides that the Enterprise will serve as a decoy.  They will make a big show of hosting the King and giving him a ride home, ignoring the fact that he is dying in sick bay, while Spock and McCoy take Kailyn in a shuttlecraft to search for the crown. This was a good plan, but the Klingons had already been tipped to the truth of the matter.

Klingon here and causing trouble

 A sneak attack causes their shuttlecraft to crash on Sigma 1212.  All three people survive, but the planet is cold so they will have to bundle up.  With their food supply spoiled they are forced to look for food.  While foraging the landing party finds themselves captured by these primitive aliens.

Back on the ship, there is major concern about the missing shuttlecraft.  Kirk talks with Admiral Harrington via subspace radio.  It is determined that the Klingons had to have been tipped off by a spy.  Considering the information that was provided it is clear that the spy had to have come from the King’s own staff.  They make it a priority to find him or her.  The best course of action, reasoned by Kirk, is to the give spy room to out themselves. 

It turns out that the local who captured the two Starfleet officers, and the Princess was hoping to sell them as slaves for a profit so he could by the latest spear with a metal tip.  He doesn’t make the sale, so their captor changes his plan and decides tomorrow he will have them as food.  The three prisoners didn’t know of this but if they did it would have just added to their desire to escape, which they do.  Once they escaped, they return to the wrecked shuttlecraft to salvage some supplies, when they find themselves attacked by wild animals.  The good news is they recovered the phasers and were able to fight them off.  The are then found by another indigenous tribe of Sigma 1212.  These however were friends of the late King Stevvin. 

Klingons on the way

Back on the Enterprise, Kirk’s plan was successful.  The traitorous spy tried to make contact with his Klingon handler, and they were both caught.  While on Sigma 1212, Princess Kailyn confesses her love to Dr. McCoy, and he tries to let her down easily, but she takes it hard.  They also discover that the Princess must pass a test set up by her late father in order to be given the sacred crown.  She fails at first but then passes after a prep talk from Mr. Spock.  In an added bonus the Klingon spy crew that were following hoping to kill the Princess were captured by the same individual who tried to sell the heroes earlier.  He is selling the Klingons and Spock encourages their new friends to purchase.  Using information taken from the Klingon captives they are able to locate the not-damaged small Klingon scout ship in order to escape from the planet with the crown in hand. 

As they leave the planet the stolen Klingon ship comes between the Enterprise and the IKS Nightwing.  Spock gets a message to the Enterprise, and they pull an emergency beam out and warp away leaving the Klingons with an empty spy ship.  

On Shad, Kailyn is crowned Queen and all that was lost is now restored.  

Additional thoughts: One of the first things I want to acknowledge is when it takes place. At the end of The Motion Picture the Enterprise and her crew stood restored waiting for their next adventure. At the start of the movie the Enterprise was just finishing up its re-fit and prepping for its next five-year-mission under Captain Decker.  Now they are fully ready to go on that mission with Captain Kirk in command.  Except as fans know we never get to see any of that.  The next film will have a time jump (yes, I am breaking my rule of not talking about later Trek) but it is important to point out we are getting to see something that we don’t normally.  To me this one of the great things about Star Trek books is they allow glimpses into time periods we don’t get to interact with much, and the missing second five-year mission is the first of those missing time periods.

Always good to get stories from this time period

The main story itself was good.  The themes of the episode have been seen many times throughout the series. It reminds me of the episodes Friday’s Child, A Private Little War, and Elaan of Troyius.  All three of those episodes and this book have the Klingons trying to destabilize a local planet or region of space so that they can exploit everything when it falls apart.  In all these stories either Kirk or McCoy has a connection to the ruling families, and one of the women in said family falls for one of the two men.  That itself isn’t a bad thing if formula works, I don’t blame them if they want to use it again.  In addition, the details in each of these stories are different enough to keep them interesting. 

1660-1685 not the time of myth
The Shad monarchy was a little confusing not to mention small.  At the start of the book the royal family is just the King, the Queen, and the Princess.  By the end of the book, it is just the newly enthroned Queen. However, if the monarchy is as old as they claim it is, shouldn’t there be some cadet branches at the very least?  The King didn’t have a sibling?  Another son of the pervious King?  What are the laws regarding succession anyways?  Proximity of the blood? Primogeniture (cognatic, agnatic-cognatic, absolute)?  Granted a lot of emphasis is placed on the sacred crown, but how real is that? Is it really the same one that the first King of Shad was given?  When discussing the origins of the monarchy, McCoy compares King Keulane and the stories about him to the myth and legends of King Arthur.  Yet, Stevvin was only the 17th monarch of that line.  Okay the present British Monarch is King Charles III who came to the Throne in 2022, now count back 16 from him and you arrive at King Charles II, who was King from 1660-1685.  Now that was a long time ago for sure, but it has hardly a time of myth.  We know quite a bit about the 17th century, it’s not a time period of the myth of King Arthur.  I think the author should have picked a bigger number than 17 when deciding King Stevvin’s number on the list of kings.   
2022-current

Also, I thought maybe the royal family puts too much stock in the crown.  How do they know it’s the same one handed down the generations?  Maybe it has fallen apart or been lost before?  I think the technology on the Enterprise exists just to make a whole new crown.  Who would know?

Nice name for the Klingon ship.  Since it is called the Nightwing if they were not big fans of the comic book character, Dick Grayson.  Then I remembered that the book came out in 1981 and he hasn’t become Nightwing yet.  Still, they could be Superman comic fans, as that is the origin of the name.

Why not name a ship after him?

Should it be canon: Yes, I have no problem with this story as canon.  In fact, it begins to fill a necessary niche in the Star Trek timeline. 

Cover Art: The cover has Kirk, Spock, and McCoy standing at the bottom of the page dressed in Motion Picture landing party gear.  In the background is a red son over a mountain range.  In front of the sun is the Enterprise with the Nightwing in pursuit.

Final Grade: Final Grade 3 of 5

 

Saturday, January 21, 2023

SPOCK BECOMES A GROWN-UP BY RUNNING WITH THE ANIMALS

 


Name: Star Trek: The New Voyages – Story 6 “The Hunting”

Author: Doris Beetem, with an introduction by Sondra Marshak and Myrna Culbreath  

Publication Date: 3/1976

Publisher: Bantam Books

Page Number: 17

Historian’s Note: Sometime after Second Season of the Animated Series   

Cast of Characters:  Captain James T. Kirk         Commander Spock              Dr. Leonard H. McCoy AKA “Bones”                           Lieutenant Nyota Uhura          

Starships and/or Starbases: USS Enterprise NCC-1701

Planets: Rhinegelt

My Spoiler filled summary and review: Once again it is shore leave time for the crew of the Enterprise.  This time, unlike our last adventure that had Dr. McCoy practically dragging a workaholic Captain Kirk off the bridge, it is the Captain practically dragging a workaholic Dr. McCoy out of sickbay.  Kirk is able to lure McCoy out with one little fact.  Mr. Spock is also taking shore leave.  Typically, the Vulcan Science Officer, likes to spend his down time meditating and conserving his energy in rest.  He has criticized in the past the human need to run around in the grass using energy rather than conserving it. This time Mr. Spock has taken out a hunting license.

Spock needed drugs to allow him to walk in the grass before

                This arouses McCoy’s suspicions and he heads down to Spock’s quarters to see if he would like some company and to his surprise Spock accepts as he is required to have a companion.  For Spock this is more than a simple hunt it is the scared Vulcan ritual called the mok farr.  It is a coming-of-age ritual, meaning that despite having a career in Starfleet where he has risen to become First Officer of the Flag Ship of the Fleet with the rank of commander, he is not by Vulcan standards an adult.  The reason Spock gives is his human half delayed his telepathic abilities and by the time they came to full force he had left Vulcan for Starfleet. His job is not simply to hunt the animal, in fact he brings no weapons with him, but to find an apex predator and perform a mind meld. 

boyhood pet who he didn't mind meld with 

                McCoy and Spock go on their way and McCoy witnesses the hunt for the owl tiger, as it is called. Spock is going to have to defeat this creature with his Vulcan strength in order to perform the mind meld.  Spock is successful in the attempt however the impact of sharing a mind with such a beast programed by nature to kill has serious effect on Spock.  He begins to assume the identity of the animal.  Even as McCoy gets them separated Spock seems lost as the beast.  He runs wild like a wild man who was raised by wolves.

                It gets bad as Spock acts violently towards McCoy and chases another animal into the wilderness.  Things get so bad that McCoy pulls a projector on out of his kit to record his last message to Kirk telling to make Spock forgive himself for what he might do in this state to McCoy.  McCoy says in the message that he brought this all on himself. The noise lures Spock back to him, he attacks but the Vulcan is distracted by the projector and slowly his sense come back to him.  The two officers return to the Enterprise and for Spock its his first time arriving there as an adult. 

Productive end

   

Additional thoughts: This is fun little story.  For all their commitment to logic it is amazing that the Vulcans will have the most outlandish rituals tied to their culture.  Although it is easy to tell the difference between an adult and a child most of the time the actual moment when someone stops being a child and becomes an adult is not so easy.  As someone who works with teenagers, I can attest to that, some of them a very mature almost indistinguishable from an adult, while others are very immature, and others are in the middle.  By “mature” I am referring to both mental and physical traits.  Some societies put as a strict number “you are an adult if you are X-age.”  Currently that age in my society is 18 (sort of).  However, if I have a random mixed group of 17-year-olds and 18-year-olds I would not be able to sort them by age without them telling me.   Yet one is supposed to be an adult while the other is a child. Then there are societies that would have their children complete a rite of passage to become an adult.  Sometimes this is a task the other times it’s just a ceremony. 

Spock in Amok Time
  

                We first learned in the episode “Journey to Babel” that Spock was not on speaking terms with his father because of his career choice.  In addition to that his mother Amanda talks with Spock about his childhood and that he was relentlessly bullied as a young child for not being “Vulcan” enough.  This was also confirmed in the episode “Yesteryear” when Spock journeyed to this past the audience got to see it upfront.  I wrote a while back that Spock joins Starfleet and surrounds himself humans not to embrace his humanity but instead to reconfirm his Vulcan-ness.

Very disappointed in Spock

                Spock says in this story that his telepathic abilities had developed late, he doesn’t mention it but you can see that is something else his bullies would torment him over.  “He is so human he can’t even mind-meld.”  The fact he left Vulcan and couldn’t complete this coming-of-age ceremony, the mok farr, would be even more torment coming in the form Vulcan gossip for him.  His old bullies could at best still see their old and clearly grown classmate as still a child, and at worst view him as a type of adult, a human one.

T'Pring and her chosen

                You would have to wonder if this would also have impacted T’Pring’s decision to abandon Spock to Stonn.  She said it was because she didn’t want to be the consort of a legend, but maybe that was T’Pring’s way of being nice.  Perhaps what she wanted to say is “Sorry Spock, I need a real man one who can mok farr before he can pon farr.”  That would have been cruel.        

This my weird way of being nice!

Should it be canon: Yes, I would love for this story to be added to the Star Trek lore.  For all the reasons I talk about above, especially with T’Pring. 

Cover Art: What I said in the review of the first story

“The cover is beautiful.  You have the Enterprise flying in all its glory in the bottom center of the image.  Behind it looks like a space station built on an asteroid.  Flying above in the opposite direction is an unknown starship whose design I don’t recognize.”  

Final Grade: Final Grade 4 of 5